Why Debt Downgrade Matters Even Though It Shouldn’t

Given the fact that bond yields of most of the euro area countries that were downgraded by Standard & Poors actually fell (contrary to what one might expect), similar by the way to how U.S. treasury yields dropped after they got downgraded by S&P, one can ask if S&P and other credit rating agencies have become irrelevant.

The short answer is: no thay haven’t, though they should.

First of all we must realize that the move was expected and therefore already more or less priced in before the formal announcement after Friday’s closing, so big changes wasn’t to be expected. And other factors, for example ECB bond buying was active in pushing down yields.

And secondly, we have a really good reason to expect ratings to matter: namely that regulation requires many fund managers to only hold bonds that have sufficiently high ratings. It was because of this that Portuguese bond yields (already the second highest after Greece’s) soared, as the downgrade forced many bond holders to sell.

But this is clearly something that should be changed. The credit ratings of credit rating agencies shouldn’t in any way be encouraged or be made a mandatory standard by governments. They shouldn’t play any role in legal accounting rules, nor in rules of which securities funds should invest in. This is both because it is principally wrong for governments to give private institutes such priviligies and because of their awful track record (to the extent they’ve been „right” it has almost always been because of the self-fulfilling prophecy mechanism).

So unfortunately, the incompetent redit rating agencies matter. But they shouldn’t.

Artykuły powiązane

The complexity of civilisation is a sign of development

Kategoria: New trends
Economic growth is underpinned by long-term technology trends. By observing them, we can make forecasts 20 to 30 years into the future. These days automation and digitalisation of the economy is key to growth: short term developments which come and go, such as economic crises, do not change the megatrends.
The complexity of civilisation is a sign of development

The United Kingdom’s Great Leap Forward

Kategoria: Business
“After Brexit, the United Kingdom is building trade links and developing its own competences in many modern sectors of the economy. This can be seen on the example of biotechnology and pharmacy – the United Kingdom has efficiently implemented its own coronavirus vaccine and is now one of the leaders in terms of vaccination,” says Dr Przemysław Biskup from the Polish Institute of International Affairs (PISM).
The United Kingdom’s Great Leap Forward